Silas John Edwards with a Holy Ground ceremonial sand painting, c. 1958

This past month, I’ve given many podcast interviews to promote my new book The Case of the Autographed Corpse: A Medicine Man and a Mystery Writer in Pursuit of Justice. So far, no interviewer has asked an obvious question: How can a white author with no tribal affiliation take on a story largely about Silas John Edwards, an Apache healer and medicine man of the early twentieth century?

My answer is that if I were ever considering writing a book about Apache culture and religion, I’d quickly strangle the idea; for many reasons, I’m the wrong person to write such a book. But that’s not what The Case of the Autographed Corpse is about. Instead, it tells a factual tale of two men from different American cultures teaming up to achieve justice by correcting a wrongful conviction. Injustice is a universal theme of wide interest, territory that should be open for exploration to all writers who are careful not to appropriate, misinterpret, or simplify another culture that isn’t theirs.

In a recent essay in The New York Times, John McWhorter gives another answer. He argues that “the very nature of creativity is to step beyond the self, an especially valuable step in a diverse society that promotes empathy.” The value of literature is in expanding specific lived experiences into stories of universal meaning, and that requires investigating the lives of people unlike the writer in some ways. Please read McWhorter’s piece and let me know what you think.

In Damn History you'll find, as usual, recommendations on good and popularly accessible historical reading, with tips on writing and updates on my own work.

Follow me on X at @Jack_ElHai, on Bluesky at @jackelhai.bsky.social, and on Threads at @jackelhai1.

Contact me by email at [email protected]

Personal Notes

For Crimereads, I wrote an essay on the ethical difficulties of using private love letters in book research.

I had a great time with author Brandy Schillace talking about my new book on her Peculiar Book Club podcast. I also spoke with Kate Winkler Dawson on the Wicked Words podcast.

Last month, Magers & Quinn Booksellers of Minneapolis hosted me and James Mayer of the Great North Innocence Project for a conversation about The Case of the Autographed Corpse. If you missed that event, you can watch a video of our discussion.

Recent Popular History from All Over

You may find some of these articles behind a paywall if you’ve exceeded the publisher’s allowance of free views.

Before photography, Americans knew what a vast variety of fruit looked like only because of the women who painted them.

History and international law allow no basis for the Trump Administration’s sanctions on war crimes judges.

What kept the friendship between Hannah Arendt and Mary McCarthy alive for decades?

There’s an explanation for the continuing presence of King Arthur in pop culture.

For centuries, labyrinths have given people a way to find themselves.

The most popular detective play in Victorian England will surprise you.

The Suitcase Bomb is one of several dangerous atomic weapons you’ve not heard of.

A writer got lost in a nineteenth-century landscape painting.

Queen Elizabeth I needed help to write her angriest letter.

Sixty-one Somali grandmothers in Minnesota preserved their history by sharing their lullabies.

Resources 

It’s always good to know which books are the world’s most valuable.

Michelin’s use of AI to write Dallas restaurant reviews has stirred up trouble.

The world’s longest biography is too big even to be a doorstop.

A judge in a history book award competition lost too much sleep.

Even at literary events, we’re plagued by “standing ovation inflation.” [audio]

Browsing in bookshops is healthy.

“Our struggle today is not to have a female Einstein get appointed as an assistant professor. It is for a woman schlemiel to get as quickly promoted as a male schlemiel.” – Bella Abzug

Housekeeping

To subscribe to Damn History, sign up here. 

More next month, and thanks for looking. And you are welcome to forward Damn History in its entirety to anyone.

About me: I'm a history and science writer. I've contributed hundreds of articles to such publications as Smithsonian, The Atlantic, The Washington Post Magazine, Wired, Scientific American, Discover, GQ, Longreads and many others. My books include The Case of the Autographed Corpse: A Medicine Man and a Mystery Writer in Pursuit of Justice; The Lost Brothers: A Family’s Decades-Long Search, The Lobotomist: A Maverick Medical Genius and His Tragic Quest to Rid the World of Mental Illness, and The Nazi and the Psychiatrist: Hermann Goering, Dr. Douglas M. Kelley, and a Fatal Meeting of Minds at the End of WW2.

I frequently give talks and lead workshops on the topics of my books as well as on the craft of nonfiction writing. To book me for your event or for media inquiries, please contact Ann Aronson at [email protected].

Please feel free to get in touch.